“Eighty percent of children have been on a diet by the time
they hit fourth grade”, both an overwhelming number and a believable statement.
Children these days are becoming more and more overweight; fatter. America has
come a long way in the need of making sure our kids are as healthy as the ‘average
weight’ for their age and size. As a child, I was overweight, I too was fat. My
doctor told my parents that I needed to pick up a sport in my spare time. Where
has this need come from to keep our children ‘healthy’, to make sure that they’re
at their physical best?
On page
35 of Fat Shame by Amy Erdman Farrell, she states that “records from the
American Medical Association indicate that many doctors needed to be convinced
of the relevance of weighing children”. This was in 1949. In current time,
2011, doctors are obsessed with weighing those of adolescence. “Oh, you’ve
seemed to have gained some weight since our last visit.” “Are you eating
healthy?” “Do you exercise?” All the seemingly innocent questions or remarks
can be hurtful and damaging to a child that age. Society has us, as Americans,
conditioned to believe that stepping on a scale is the right thing to do, that
losing weight is important, that being thin is superior. This societal movement
towards being thin has been conditioned in our brains to attack those who may
struggle with their weight, causing a chain that leads down to children.
Last
year, Beyonce was asked to change her song “Get Me Bodied” to “Move Your Body”,
a weight-loss song for kids. (See video at bottom of page.) In the song, the
lyrics are all different dances that were popular, and still are, at the time,
such as ‘The Dougie’ and ‘The Catdaddy’. Throughout the song there isn’t a
point where you aren’t moving. Last year in school, we decided to try and learn
the dance and our results show that it definitely makes you sweat. This
song/dance was partnered with First Lady Obama’s Anti-Child Obesity campaign, and
was performed by a group of kids at a neighboring school.
The
fact that our First Lady and a popular music artist are both encouraging kids
to get out and move their bodies shows just what our society has become towards
the ways of fat shame. However, these two influential people aren’t the only
ones pushing children to explore other possibilities. Every year for an entire
day Nickelodeon doesn’t play any TV shows and instead has a scrolling screen telling
kids to get out and move. When I was younger, I would just change the channel,
and I’m sure I’m not the only person to preform this act. Yet, the purpose
behind this day shows that even television companies whose main goal is to have
child viewers put aside days each year to make kids move away from their TVs
and exercise or just get outside.
In the
book, Farrell also touches on the movie Wall-E. Although she doesn’t aim her
points at childhood obesity and the culture’s obsession with correcting
children’s weight problems, which is what I thought of while reading about
Wall-E. This Pixar movie shows what our society can become if we decide to let
our weight go and allow machines to take over for us. We too could be carted around
on machines and not have the correct muscles to stand. Wall-E shows kids that 'letting your body go' isn’t the right way to go about things and therefore
should make sure to get physical exercise.
Our
obsession with children’s weight has increased a lot since the days where doctors
didn’t even want to weigh them. In doing this, are we helping children and
sculpting them for their futures? Or are we just helping our own opinions and
making ourselves feel better?
Dana, I turned on the TV this morning and happened upon Mousekercise. Mickey Mouses version of getting kids to exercise and stay healthy. I found this slightly ironic because tv is usually frowned upon by parents because it rots brains and makes couch potatoes (very frightening things to say to a small child), but perhaps it is okay if it is promoting children to stay fit? Here is a link I found about the show from a mothers perspective.
ReplyDeletehttp://fitbottomedmamas.com/2011/03/get-the-kids-moving-with-mickey-mouse/
I am not convinced mousekercise is completely bad or completely good. Your blog entry reminded me of this specific case because parents are citizens that have obligations to bring up future citizens ie. their children. A child can be interpreted as a reflection of their parents. If your child is fat, this can be seen as a lack of control by the parents because children are still navigating their future relations with citizenship.
"The fact that our First Lady and a popular music artist are both encouraging kids to get out and move their bodies shows just what our society has become towards the ways of fat shame."
ReplyDeleteI don't see this as negative, actually. I wrote about Farrell's interpretation of WALL-E and I disagree in many ways. There is nothing wrong with wanting kids/people to MOVE. So much is done for us these days through technology, and so many jobs are sedentary, so moving wouldn't be a bad idea. The shift from playing outside to playing video games changed the way bodies looked, and of course, moved. These efforts don't bother me because you can be active and healthy and still be considered fat. I don't think this campaign is against FAT, as much as it is against not-being-able-to-move/health-risks.
Bridgette- I watched the video after reading the article and I was shocked with the ideas Disney is coming up with these days to get kids active. However, I must agree that the little jingle was quite catchy and might possibly even get some of my friends moving or my extremely stubborn nephew. I think the bad in this case would be that parents have to sit their children in front of a TV to get exercise instead of taking them outside or signing them up for sports. The good would be that they too are getting up and moving.
ReplyDeleteVicki- I understand where you're coming from and I can agree that yes, these ideas are about getting up to 'move'. However, I still do believe that it's about getting children to not become fat, to take away obesity, or what some doctors may consider obesity. For example, my friend is a football player and a wrestler and when he gets on his Wii Fit it tells him he is obese. By looking at him you can tell this is not the case, yet some doctors may say this based on weight along and not factoring his muscle mass into account. Adding to the idea that not all concepts of obesity or 'fat' are in fact correct.